Ugly animals also deserve conservation
2021-06-14
Thinking aesthetically when it comes to biodiversity threatens the balance of nature, writes Brian Danley and colleagues in a new scientific article.

Cute animals are valued higher than ugly endangered animals. The proximity to the endangered species also affects our willingness to save it. Thinking aesthetically when it comes to biodiversity threatens the balance of nature, writes Brian Danley and colleagues in a new scientific article.
Humans prefer to preserve animal species with which they are familiar, which they regard as charming or animals with a strong symbolic value, even if these species are at a lower risk of extinction. An ugly and unknown animal species thus runs a much greater risk of extinction. Human preferences can change when the distance between humans and an ugly endangered species decreases; then people living closer to an unknown species may feel a greater commitment to save the species. An international team of researchers has recently tested this theory in a study examining people's attitude and willingness to save five different fish species in Lake Lough Melvin in northwestern Ireland. The authors of the report "Putting your best fish forward" are Brian Danley, Assistant Senior Lecturer in Sustainable Development at the Department of Earth Sciences, Erlend Dancke at the School of Economics and Business at the Norwegian University of Life Sciences, and Danny Campbell at Applied Choice Research Group, University of Stirling Management School, Scotland, UK.
Tell us briefly about the report
- We have studied how people tend to prioritize between five different fish species. What we see is that we are willing to spend more time and money saving a species we are already familiar with compared to a species that is less known to us but significantly more endangered. This behavior is reflected elsewhere. It is no coincidence that many organizations use the panda as a logo to show that they are involved in animal and environmental issues. The polar bear and the tiger are also symbolic animals that elicit public interest. Using such animals even has its own name; "conservation marketing," which involves using an animal that people immediately recognize so that people become more willing to invest money to preserve that species. Imagine how many times you have seen a panda in a bamboo bush or a polar bear in beautiful Arctic environments used as a flagship in a campaign. The environment in which the animals live also matters. If it is an environment we have seen before and recognize, we are more likely to try to save that animal species. Another factor is similarities with humans. The more similarities, the more benevolent we become. A blobfish is an animal species that does not resemble humans at all, it is not perceived as cute and is not well known, in the same way as the fish we examined.
Did you come up with something new in the study?
- We see that those study participants who live relatively close to the more unknown fish species are those who value the relatively unknown species higher. The proximity to an endangered species thus comes into play. Simply put, we see two kinds of categories of people willing to save endangered species; the ones who recognize the species and then there are those who are willing to save the species because they are in the vicinity of the species.
Those for whom the species is unknown and those who are at a longer distance from the endangered species care the least. There is a great danger in this result because there are many endangered species that fulfill an important task in the ecosystem, but they do not meet human requirements for beauty or charisma and they do not live in our vicinity.
Read the article “Putting your best fish forward: Investigating distance decay and relative preferences for fish conservation” in the Journal of Environmental Economics and Management.
For more information contact Brian Danley, Erlend Dancke Sandorf, or Danny Campbell.
News from the Department of Earth Sciences
-
Forskare varnar för katastrofal klimatutveckling
-
"Coping with COP", förstå vad FN:s klimatkonferens handlar om
-
Simon Pieslinger prisas för sin masteruppsats i geovetenskap
-
"Vulkanforskare ska avslöja lavans hemligheter på Island"
-
Prof. Troll inaugurated as Member of the Royal Academy of Sciences of the Canary Islands
-
Mariia Netsyk and Thomas Stevens awarded 2 227 277 kr from “MSCA-for Ukraine 2023 Vetenskapsrådet”
-
Big ERC grant to Troll for research on volcanoes
-
60 miljoner till nytt centrum för strategiska metaller
-
Premiär för Wiebren Boonstras tv-föreläsning om samhällsomställning
-
Premiär för Giuliano Di Baldassarres tv-föreläsning om översvämning och torka
-
Flera av våra forskare på Stanford Universitys "World’s top 2% scientists, 2023"
-
Stacy VanDeveer´s installationsföreläsning
-
Förmodad sprängning vid gasledningen i Finska viken
-
Pressmeddelande: Vissa extremväderhändelser på vintern dubbelt så vanliga som på 1950-talet
-
Två nya kurser i klimatledarskap - livslångt lärande
Under våren 2024 är det premiär för två nya kurser i klimatledarskap; Klimatledarskap i näringslivet (3hp) och Klimatledarskap i politik och förvaltning (3hp). Kurserna ges på distans och på kvällstid och anmälan är öppen fram till och med 16 oktober 2023.
-
21 september 2023 var det varmaste dygnet på 300 år
Tyckte du att det var varmt igår? Ja, då hade du helt rätt. Dygnsmedeltemperaturen den 21 september, alltså medelvärdet på dygnet var 18.3 grader, vilket är den varmaste temperatur som har uppmätts så sent i september på 301 år. Det berättar meteorologerna vid institutionen för geovetenskaper, där vädret har uppmätts sedan 1722.
-
Stacy VanDeveer är ny professor i klimatledarskap
-
ClimaMeter: a new meteorological approach helps us understand extreme weather events
-
Life in the ocean is the focus for the major new EU project BioEcoOcean
-
Scientists explain: this is how ancient material is dated
-
He will be studying the effects of extreme weather
-
The sand dunes reveal how climate changes affect the Arctic landscape and its stability over time
-
Nytt Horizon Europe-projekt beviljat
-
Östersjödagarna vill ge havet en röst
-
Nytt excellenscenter ska undersöka effekterna av extrema klimathändelser
-
Can we transition to a society that respects biodiversity?
-
1,350,000 sek funding for a 1 year project on The Past Climates of Jersey
-
Stort anslag till forskning om klimatet och naturen
-
First place in making research more sustainable
-
Breaking the isolation of Ukrainian university teachers
-
Mikael Höök är ny föreståndare för CEMUS
-
Europeiskt samarbete gör det lättare att förutsäga framtidens klimat
-
Minuscule fossil finds shed light on the aftermath of the Cambrian Explosion
-
Energi från underjorden kan bli en del av framtidens energiförsörjning
-
Wide income gaps lead to higher mortality rates during flood disasters
-
Urban water crises driven by elites’ unsustainable consumption
-
Atmosfäriska cirkulationsmönster bidrar till extremväder
-
Nöjda doktorander på Geocentrum
-
Turné mot vetenskapsförnekelse
-
Slutrapport från Expertgruppen för hållbara mineral- och metallflöden
-
6 miljoner kronor till projekt som ska undersöka svenska litiumfyndigheter
-
Skatterna man tappade: metaller och mineral i gruvavfall
-
Akademiföreläsning med Anna Rutgersson: Extremväder i ett föränderligt klimat
-
International research project will study past climate changes in the European Arctic
-
Keen to see more applied environmental policy research
-
Björn Lund om jordbävningen i Turkiet och Syrien
-
Veijo Pohjola: "Iskärnor kan avslöja hemligheter om klimatet"
-
Worms, bacteria and fungi help reduce carbon dioxide emissions
-
The planet’s wellbeing and human health in focus in this year’s Celsius-Linnaeus Lectures
-
A 1 669 665 SEK grant from The European Research Council enhances our knowledge around extreme weather events